What it is
Toddler after a new baby is common. A potty-trained two-year-old wets again. A good sleeper wakes. A sweet child hits. Two under two is its own kind of hard. The older child has lost their place and has no words for it.
What's typical
Regression and jealousy show up in the first weeks and often last two to three months. Many children ignore the baby, then get too rough, then settle into interest. Setbacks usually pass on their own. Hitting the baby is common and is about the child, not the baby.
What's known
The AAP describes regression as a normal response to change and advises patience over correction. Studies find that ten minutes of one-on-one time a day with the older child makes a real difference.
What helps
- Ten minutes a day of the older child's choosing, with no baby in your arms.
- Keep their routine as close to normal as you can. Same daycare, same bedtime.
- Give them a job: fetch the diaper, pick the song.
- Say the feeling for them. 'You wish the baby would go back.' Then hold them.
When to call someone
- Nowa baby who was hit or shaken and seems sleepy, limp, or vomits. Go in.
- Todaythe older child stops eating, has night terrors most nights, or hurts themselves.
- At your next visitregression past three months, or rage at the older child that scares you. Both have help.
What it is
Toddler after a new baby is common. A potty-trained two-year-old has accidents again. A good sleeper wakes at night. A sweet child hits, clings, or talks in baby talk. 'Two under two' is its own kind of hard. The older child has lost their place and often has no words for it.
Why does it happen? A sibling's arrival is one of a young child's first big changes in the family. Before, the child had a parent's whole attention. Now the parent is tired, busy feeding, and hard to share. In a classic study of families in Cambridge, England, Judy Dunn and Carol Kendrick found that after a new baby came, mothers' playful time with the older child dropped and their confrontations with that child rose (Dunn and Kendrick 1982). Toddlers cannot yet say 'I miss you,' so feelings come out as behavior: wetting, waking, clinging, and sometimes hitting. Regression is how many young children show stress.
What's typical
Most firstborns show some change in behavior in the first weeks or months. In early studies, many mothers reported clinginess, sleep trouble, toileting setbacks, or naughtiness (Dunn, Kendrick, and MacNamee 1981). A later review of more than 30 years of studies found a mixed picture. Many children became more withdrawn or aggressive in the early months, and many also showed new interest and affection toward the baby (Volling 2012, Psychological Bulletin). Setbacks usually pass on their own, often within a few months, though some children take longer.
Many children ignore the baby at first, then get too rough, then settle into interest. Hitting or squeezing the baby is common and reflects the child's feelings and limited impulse control, not a verdict on the baby or on you. Sleep terrors, in which a child seems awake and frightened but cannot be comforted, are common in toddlers even without a new sibling (Petit 2015).
What's known
The AAP describes regression as a normal response to change and advises patience over correction. Researchers have found that children adjust better when a parent stays warm and responsive. One-to-one time is a common recommendation, and parent-training programs such as Parent-Child Interaction Therapy teach short, child-led play sessions. The oft-quoted ten minutes a day is a convention drawn from these programs, not a number tested for new siblings. Naming a child's feeling before correcting behavior, which researchers call emotion coaching, is linked with better emotional regulation in children (Gottman, Katz, and Hooven 1996).
A review of advice for welcoming a second child found that most of it had never been tested (Kramer and Ramsburg 2002). Family stress matters. A depressed or overwhelmed parent, or conflict between parents, makes adjustment harder (Teti 1996), and maternal depression is linked with more behavior problems in children (Goodman 2011).
What helps
- Ten minutes a day of the older child's choosing, with no baby in your arms and no phone.
- Keep their routine as close to normal as you can. Same childcare, same bedtime. Many families avoid starting potty training or moving a child out of the crib around the birth.
- Give them a job: fetch the diaper, pick the song, hold the baby with you sitting beside them.
- Say the feeling for them. 'You wish the baby would go back.' Then hold them.
- The AAP advises never leaving a baby alone with a toddler, even a gentle one, since a hug can become a squeeze.
When to call someone
- Nowa baby who was hit or shaken and seems sleepy, limp, or vomits. Go in. Call 911 if the baby is hard to wake or not breathing normally.
- Todaythe older child stops eating, has night terrors most nights, or hurts themselves. Call the pediatrician.
- At your next visitregression past three months, or rage at the older child that scares you. Both have help, so say it out loud to your provider.
Written as a review for birthworkers and readers of papers. It describes practice; it does not instruct, and it carries no doses.
Overview
The birth of a sibling is a normative family that commonly produces transient behavioral and emotional change in the older child, including in toileting, sleep disturbance, clinginess, aggression, and withdrawal. For most children these changes are time-limited; for a minority they persist and signal an adjustment problem or reflect parental distress. The clinical tasks are to normalize typical adjustment, identify children and families at higher risk, ensure infant safety, and recognize when maternal mood is part of the picture.
Mechanism
Contemporary accounts combine , family-systems, and social-learning perspectives. The arrival of a sibling reduces and changes the older child's access to parental attention and alters parental behavior: Dunn and Kendrick (Siblings: Love, Envy and Understanding, 1982) documented a decline in maternal playful interaction and an increase in confrontation with the firstborn. For toddlers, limited language and emotional regulation channel distress into behavior. Regression is interpreted as a stress response and bid for caregiving rather than a loss of capacity. Teti and colleagues (Child Development 1996) found that firstborns' to the mother was affected by the quality of the mother-child relationship and the marital relationship across the transition, supporting the view that family climate moderates the child's adjustment. Child factors, including age, temperament, and prior attachment quality, also matter; age effects are inconsistent across studies. These mechanisms are inferred from observational data.
Epidemiology
Most children in the United States and other high-income countries who have a sibling experience this transition, most commonly between ages two and five. In the early prospective studies, a large proportion of firstborns showed at least one change in behavior within the first months, including clinginess, sleep problems, regression, and oppositional behavior (Dunn, Kendrick, and MacNamee 1981). Volling's review (Psychological Bulletin 2012) concluded that, at the group level, firstborns show increases in both internalizing and externalizing problems around the birth alongside gains in positive sibling interaction, and that most return toward baseline within months. Risk factors for poorer adjustment include parental depression, marital conflict, and low parental sensitivity. Maternal depression is associated with child behavior problems with small-to-moderate effect sizes (Goodman 2011, Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review). Sleep terrors in early childhood are common in general (Petit 2015, JAMA Pediatrics).
Clinical picture
Clinicians look at what changed, when, and how severe, and compare behavior with the child's baseline and age. Typical adjustment: new regressive or oppositional behaviors beginning within days to weeks of the birth, fluctuating, responsive to attention, and not accompanied by loss of other skills or wide impairment. Concerning features: persistence beyond about three months, escalating aggression, self-injury, refusal to eat, severe or daily sleep disturbance, loss of language or social skills, or persistent fear or distress out of proportion.
The differential includes (DSM-5-TR: emotional or behavioral symptoms within three months of a stressor, out of proportion to it or causing impairment), anxiety and separation anxiety, medical contributors to toileting regression such as constipation and urinary tract infection, sleep disorders, developmental conditions that surface at this age, exposure to trauma or maltreatment, and effects of parental depression or conflict. Any head or body injury to an infant is evaluated regardless of who caused it, and infants are never considered safe when left alone with a toddler. or rage in the mother is screened, since it changes both the child's course and the mother's needs.
Evidence
The core evidence is observational. Dunn and Kendrick's Cambridge studies (1981, 1982) established the descriptive picture and the change in mother-child interaction. Volling (2012) synthesized the empirical literature on firstborn adjustment. Teti and colleagues (1996) linked attachment outcomes to family relationships. Baydar, Greek, and Brooks-Gunn (1997) followed children over six years and found modest, mostly short-lived effects. Kramer and Ramsburg (Family Relations 2002) reviewed advice to parents and found it largely untested, including prenatal sibling preparation.
For interventions, evidence comes from the broader parenting literature: group parent training for early conduct problems reduces child behavior problems (Furlong 2012, Cochrane), and Parent-Child Interaction Therapy has strong trial support in preschoolers with disruptive behavior. These are not tested for the specific sibling transition. The recommended ten minutes of daily one-to-one time is a convention, not a trial-derived dose. Emotion coaching is supported by observational and intervention studies of parental meta-emotion (Gottman 1996). The AAP and Zero to Three issue consensus guidance. The main limitation is that most studies are of two-parent families in high-income countries.
Management landscape
Standard practice is in pregnancy and at newborn visits: prepare the child in age-appropriate ways, keep routines stable, avoid unrelated big transitions near the birth, and build in one-to-one time and roles for the older child. Clinicians reassure that regression is expected, review safety (supervision of the toddler with the infant, and safe handling), screen the mother for depression and anxiety, and ask about sleep. Persistent or severe problems prompt pediatric evaluation for medical causes and referral for child or family therapy or parent training. The pediatrician also advises about toilet training and sleep. and family help can protect one-to-one time. Where parental anger or rage is a concern, perinatal mental health care is the route.
When to call someone
- Nowan infant who was hit or shaken and is sleepy, limp, vomiting, or hard to wake. Go in; call 911 if the baby is hard to wake or not breathing normally.
- Todaythe older child stops eating, has sleep terrors most nights, or self-harms. Call the pediatrician.
- At your next visitregression past three months, or rage toward the older child that frightens you. Both have help.
Open questions
Which preparation strategies actually help is largely untested, including the common ten minutes of daily time. How the transition unfolds for children of different ages, in single-parent and same-sex households, and across cultures is under-studied. It is unclear which children go on to persistent problems and whether early screening would help them.
Key terms
Literature
- Dunn J, Kendrick C — Siblings: Love, Envy and Understanding. Harvard University Press, 1982
- Dunn J, Kendrick C, MacNamee R — The reaction of first-born children to the birth of a sibling: mothers' reports. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 1981
- Volling BL — Family transitions following the birth of a sibling: an empirical review of changes in the firstborn's adjustment. Psychological Bulletin 2012
- Teti DM et al. — And baby makes four: predictors of attachment security among preschool-age firstborns during the transition from two to three children. Child Development 1996
- Kramer L, Ramsburg D — Advice given to parents on welcoming a second child: a critical review. Family Relations 2002
- Gottman JM, Katz LF, Hooven C — Parental meta-emotion philosophy and the emotional life of families. Journal of Family Psychology 1996
- Goodman SH et al. — Maternal depression and child psychopathology: a meta-analytic review. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review 2011
- Furlong M et al. — Behavioural and cognitive-behavioural group-based parenting programmes for early-onset conduct problems in children aged 3 to 12 years. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2012
- Petit D et al. — Childhood sleepwalking and sleep terrors: a longitudinal study of prevalence and familial aggregation. JAMA Pediatrics 2015
- American Academy of Pediatrics — HealthyChildren.org patient pages on sibling rivalry and preparing for a new baby, 2023
Who helps
Tools: Postpartum Prep Checklist
Related
- Preparing an older child for the babyPregnancy: Mind and Life
- Postpartum ragePostpartum: Mind
- What a partner does in the first weeksSupport, Home, and Village
- The mental loadPostpartum: Mind
What mothers here say
No one has posted under this topic yet. The first experience here will help the next mother who searches for it at 2 a.m.
Experiences and questions are their authors' own, not reviewed advice. The topic's steward lists the ones that help most in a credited digest once there is one. Unusual experiences stay, with a note.
Sources
- American Academy of Pediatrics (HealthyChildren.org) — Sibling rivalry and preparing your family for a new baby
- Zero to Three — Parent resources on toddlers and new siblings
Sources are named, not yet linked. The steward verifies each one and adds the link.
Steward this topic
Birthworkers listed in our directory can claim a topic, verify its sources, and curate what mothers share here. Your name and credential go at the top of the page. Takes about an hour the first time.
Find your directory page