What it is
Your nipples are sore, or cracked, or bleeding, and you are dreading the next feed.
Some tenderness is normal early. The nipple is being pulled into a shape it has never been in, eight to twelve times a day. What is not normal is pain that lasts the whole feed, skin that cracks or bleeds, or a nipple that comes out flattened like a new lipstick. Those point to a shallow latch, a position that pulls, a , or a that is the wrong size.
What's typical
Tenderness peaks around day three to six and fades by two weeks. Latch-on pain in the first 20 to 30 seconds that then eases is common in week one. Up to eight in ten mothers report some soreness. About one in three gets a crack.
Once the cause is found and changed, cracks often start to close within a few days. Blood in the milk is safe for the baby and does not need to be thrown away.
What's known
The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine says persistent pain is a sign to look for a cause, not something to push through. A Cochrane review found no cream, including lanolin, clearly better than expressed milk or nothing for healing. Silver cups, hydrogel pads, and lanolin all have fans and little study. They are low-risk, and the latch is still the thing to change.
What helps
- Get the latch looked at this week, not next. Many hospitals and offices offer free visits.
- Nose to nipple, wait for a wide open mouth, then bring the baby in chin first. More below the nipple than above.
- Break the suction with a finger in the corner of the mouth before taking the baby off.
- Start feeds on the less sore side. Try a different position so the pressure lands somewhere new.
- Air dry after feeds. A little expressed milk rubbed in, or a cream if you like one. Change damp pads often.
- Check your pump flange size. A flange that rubs the nipple wall causes damage on its own.
When to call someone
- Todaya crack with pus or yellow crust, a fever, a red hot breast, or pain so bad you are skipping feeds.
- Todaythe baby is not gaining, has fewer wet diapers than expected, or cannot stay latched.
- This weekpain that lasts past the first 30 seconds of a feed, or past two weeks. Book a lactation consultant.
- At your next visitnipples that are white, blue, or burning after feeds, or pain with no visible damage.
What it is
Nipple pain is one of the most common reasons mothers stop breastfeeding earlier than they planned, and the usual cause is mechanical. In a deep latch the nipple sits far back in the baby's mouth, near where the hard palate meets the soft palate, and the tongue works on the breast tissue below it. In a shallow latch the nipple sits forward, against the hard palate, and gets squeezed and rubbed with every suck, 40 to 60 times a minute, eight to twelve times a day. That compression is what makes a nipple come out flattened or creased like a new lipstick, and over days it breaks the skin.
Anything that keeps the baby from taking a deep mouthful can cause it: positioning that pulls, a tight from , a restricted tongue (, or tongue-tie), a high palate, a sleepy or premature baby with a weak suck, or an inverted nipple. Pumping adds its own version: a that is too small rubs the nipple wall, and one too large draws the areola into the tunnel. Once skin is broken, bacteria on the skin, usually , can infect the crack.
What's typical
Some tenderness at latch-on in the first week is common; it peaks around days three to six and eases by two weeks. In a Melbourne cohort of 360 first-time mothers (Buck and colleagues, 2014), 79 percent reported nipple pain and 58 percent had visible damage in the first eight weeks, with most pain starting in week one. By eight weeks most had resolved, but about one in five still had pain. The useful distinction is timing within a feed. Pain in the first 20 to 30 seconds that then fades is typical of early weeks. Pain that lasts the whole feed, pain between feeds, or any crack, scab, or bleeding points to a cause that needs changing. Once the cause is corrected, shallow cracks usually begin to close within two to five days. Blood in milk from a cracked nipple is harmless to the baby.
What's known
The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine's protocol on persistent breastfeeding pain (2016) says that pain beyond the first days is a sign to find a cause, and that the first step is a skilled observation of a full feed. A Cochrane review by Dennis and colleagues (2014) pooled four trials, 656 women, of lanolin, expressed milk, glycerin gel pads, and an all-purpose nipple ointment; no product was clearly better than applying nothing or expressed milk, and all groups improved over 7 to 10 days. A later randomized trial (Jackson and Dennis 2017, 186 women) found lanolin no better than usual care. Silver nipple cups have one small trial (Marrazzu 2015, 40 women) suggesting less damage; hydrogel pads have small trials with mixed results. These products are low-risk, but the evidence says the latch, not the cream, is what heals the nipple. Where evidence is thin: there are no trials of flange sizing, and the benefit of for pain is real for some babies but hard to predict.
What helps
- Get the latch watched this week, not next. Many hospitals, offices, and La Leche League groups offer free help.
- Nose to nipple, wait for a wide gape, then bring the baby in chin first so more areola is in the mouth below the nipple than above.
- Break the suction with a clean finger in the corner of the mouth before taking the baby off.
- Start feeds on the less sore side, and change positions so the pressure lands somewhere new. Laid-back positions let the baby take a deeper mouthful.
- After feeds: air dry, a little expressed milk rubbed in, or a cream or hydrogel pad if you prefer one. Change damp pads often.
- Check the flange size if you pump. A flange that rubs the nipple wall, or pulls in the areola, damages on its own.
- If you dread feeds, a short break with pumping or on the worst side can bridge the gap while the cause is sorted out.
When to call someone
- Todaya crack with pus or yellow crust, a fever, a red hot breast, or pain so bad you are skipping feeds.
- Todaythe baby is not gaining, has fewer wet diapers than expected, or cannot stay latched.
- This weekpain that lasts past the first 30 seconds of a feed, or past two weeks. Book a lactation consultant.
- At your next visitnipples that are white, blue, or burning after feeds, or pain with no visible damage.
Written as a review for birthworkers and readers of papers. It describes practice; it does not instruct, and it carries no doses.
Overview
Nipple pain and are the leading modifiable causes of early breastfeeding cessation in high-income settings and the most frequent reason for lactation consultation in the first two weeks. The condition is almost always mechanical in origin, with infection, dermatitis, and as secondary or alternative diagnoses. The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine's Clinical Protocol #26 (Berens et al. 2016, 'Persistent pain with breastfeeding') frames assessment around observation of a feed and a structured differential. Topical products, the focus of most consumer attention, have the weakest evidence.
Mechanism
During effective breastfeeding the nipple elongates to roughly twice its resting length and lies in the posterior oral cavity near the junction of hard and soft palate. Ultrasound studies by Geddes and colleagues (2008, Early Human Development) show milk removal is driven primarily by generated as the tongue lowers, rather than by peristaltic stripping alone. In a shallow latch the nipple tip sits forward against the hard palate, is compressed between tongue and palate with each cycle, and is subjected to frictional shear; infants with poor transfer compensate with higher vacuum (McClellan et al. 2008), adding to tissue stress. Repeated compression produces the post-feed deformation (a creased or 'lipstick' nipple), then erythema, edema, epidermal loss, fissures, and eschar. Pumping injury follows the same principles: a tunnel too narrow causes friction on the nipple shaft, and one too wide draws areolar tissue in and compresses ducts.
Infant contributors include , high arched palate, micrognathia, , prematurity, and producing an . Maternal contributors include inverted or flat nipples, areolar edema from or intravenous fluids, and prior nipple surgery. Once the epidermal barrier is breached, colonizes and can produce frank infection; Amir et al. (2013, BMJ Open, CASTLE study) found S. aureus colonization strongly associated with nipple damage. Secondary processes, including vasospasm triggered by compression and cold, and dermatitis from topical products, prolong pain after the primary injury is corrected. Acute nociceptive pain can be followed by sensitization, one reason pain sometimes outlasts visible healing.
Epidemiology
Nipple pain in the first week is near universal in some series; Ziemer et al. (1990) documented soreness in up to 96 percent of mothers in the first days. The best prospective data are from the Melbourne CASTLE cohort: Buck et al. 2014 (Breastfeeding Medicine, 360 primiparas) found 79 percent reported nipple pain and 58 percent nipple damage in the first eight weeks, with onset predominantly in week one; 23 percent reported vasospasm; by eight weeks 20 percent still had pain. Kent et al. 2015 (1,177 referrals to a breastfeeding center) found nipple pain the presenting problem in about a third of early referrals, with positioning and the attributed cause in the majority. In US survey data (Odom et al. 2013, Pediatrics), pain was among the leading reasons for stopping breastfeeding in the first month. Risk factors: , flat or inverted nipples, engorgement, infant tongue restriction, a poorly fitted pump, and late-preterm infants. Persistent pain beyond two weeks is reported by roughly 10 to 20 percent of breastfeeding mothers.
Clinical picture
Assessment per ABM #26 begins with history: onset relative to birth, timing within the feed (latch-on only versus throughout versus after), bilaterality, pain quality (sharp, burning, , deep), and pump use with flange size. Examination looks for erythema, edema, fissures (a at the base suggests compression by a shallow latch; one across the tip suggests friction), eschar, exudate, scale, vesicles, blanching, and nipple shape immediately after a feed. The score and the Nipple Trauma Score are used for documentation more than diagnosis. An observed full feed assesses positioning, gape, lip flange, chin contact, rhythm, swallowing, and the nipple's shape on release; infant oral examination assesses tongue mobility (the or the Bristol Tongue Assessment Tool), palate, and jaw.
The differential, as ABM #26 lays it out: mechanical trauma from latch or pump (most common); bacterial infection, suggested by purulent exudate, honey-colored crust, spreading erythema, or non-healing over several days; dermatitis, , or psoriasis, suggested by scale, itching, and lichenification, sometimes after a new topical product; , suggested by blanching then cyanosis or rubor after feeds with throbbing or burning pain, worse in cold; candidal infection, suggested by a shiny or flaky with burning pain radiating into the breast, though the diagnosis is overcalled (see the thrush entry); herpes simplex, with grouped vesicles, which contraindicates feeding from that breast until healed; a bleb; and rarely , a unilateral eczematous change that does not heal, referred for biopsy. Infant weight and output are checked at the same visit because nipple pain and poor transfer share causes.
Evidence
Mechanics: Geddes et al. 2008 and McClellan et al. 2008 (Acta Paediatrica) supply the ultrasound and vacuum data. Epidemiology: Buck 2014 and Kent 2015, above; Amir 2013 on S. aureus. Treatment: Dennis, Jackson, and Watson's Cochrane review 2014 ('Interventions for treating painful nipples among breastfeeding women', 4 trials, 656 women) compared glycerin gel dressings, lanolin, breast shells with lanolin, expressed breast milk, and an all-purpose nipple ointment; no intervention was superior, pain resolved in all groups by 7 to 10 days, and the authors concluded that applying nothing or expressed milk may be as good as any product. Jackson and Dennis 2017 (Maternal and Child Nutrition, RCT, 186 women) found lanolin did not reduce pain or improve breastfeeding duration versus usual care. Marrazzu et al. 2015 (Breastfeeding Medicine, RCT, 40 women) reported fewer fissures with silver-impregnated cups; the trial is small and unblinded. Livingstone and Stringer 1999 (Journal of Human Lactation, RCT, 84 women with S. aureus-positive fissures) found oral antibiotics healed infected cracks better than topical measures alone, which underpins the ABM recommendation to treat frank infection systemically.
On for ankyloglossia, O'Shea et al. 2017 Cochrane (5 trials, 302 infants) found a short-term reduction in maternal nipple pain with low-quality evidence and no clear effect on breastfeeding outcomes; the debate over indications is unresolved. Flange sizing and have no trial evidence. Overall quality of evidence for treatment is low; the most consistent finding is that correcting the mechanical cause resolves most cases within days.
Management landscape
Standard practice, following ABM #26 and most national breastfeeding bodies, is early skilled assessment with an observed feed, correction of positioning and attachment, and treatment of any identified infant factor; this alone resolves most cases. During healing, clinicians describe moist wound healing (expressed milk, lanolin, or hydrogel by preference, since none has shown superiority), dry breast pads, and starting feeds on the less affected side. Where latching is intolerable, a temporary nipple shield, or a short period of expressing from the affected breast with milk given by cup, spoon, syringe, or bottle, bridges while the cause is addressed; flange fit is checked at the same time. Infected fissures are treated per ABM with topical antibiotic class agents for mild cases and systemic anti-staphylococcal agents for spreading or non-healing infection. Dermatitis is managed with removal of the trigger and a low to moderate potency class agent, per ABM. Vasospasm, candidal infection, and blebs have their own pathways (see the thrush entry). Frenotomy is offered selectively where a functional assessment supports tongue restriction. Analgesia compatible with breastfeeding ( or acetaminophen class) is standard. ABM and the AAP both state that a mother should not be advised to push through persistent pain, since pain predicts cessation and often indicates poor transfer.
When to call someone
- Todaya fissure with pus or yellow crust (signs of bacterial infection), a fever, a red hot breast, or pain so bad you are skipping feeds.
- Todaythe infant is not gaining, has fewer wet diapers than expected, or cannot stay latched; nipple pain and poor transfer share causes.
- This weekpain that lasts past the first 30 seconds of a feed, or past two weeks. Book a lactation consultant for an observed feed.
- At your next visitnipples that are white, blue, or burning after feeds (possible vasospasm), or pain with no visible damage.
Open questions
Why a minority of mothers develop persistent pain after the latch is corrected, and how much of that is versus occult infection or , is unknown. Which infants benefit from frenotomy, and by what assessment criteria, remains the most contested question in the field. Whether any topical product shortens healing when the mechanical cause has already been fixed has not been shown. Pump flange sizing rests on convention and awaits study.
Key terms
Literature
- Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine (Berens P, Eglash A, Malloy M, Steube AM) — Clinical Protocol #26: Persistent pain with breastfeeding. Breastfeeding Medicine 2016
- Dennis CL, Jackson K, Watson J — Interventions for treating painful nipples among breastfeeding women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2014
- Buck ML, Amir LH, Cullinane M, Donath SM (CASTLE study) — Nipple pain, damage, and vasospasm in the first 8 weeks postpartum. Breastfeeding Medicine 2014
- Kent JC et al. — Nipple pain in breastfeeding mothers: incidence, causes and treatments. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2015
- Amir LH et al. — Does Candida and/or Staphylococcus play a role in nipple and breast pain in lactation? A cohort study in Melbourne, Australia. BMJ Open 2013
- Jackson KT, Dennis CL — Lanolin for the treatment of nipple pain in breastfeeding women: a randomized controlled trial. Maternal and Child Nutrition 2017
- Geddes DT et al. — Tongue movement and intra-oral vacuum in breastfeeding infants. Early Human Development 2008
- McClellan HL et al. — Infants of mothers with persistent nipple pain exert strong sucking vacuums. Acta Paediatrica 2008
- Marrazzu A et al. — Evaluation of the effectiveness of a silver-impregnated medical cap for topical treatment of nipple fissure of breastfeeding mothers. Breastfeeding Medicine 2015
- O'Shea JE et al. — Frenotomy for tongue-tie in newborn infants. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2017
- Livingstone V, Stringer LJ — The treatment of Staphylococcus aureus infected sore nipples: a randomized comparative study. Journal of Human Lactation 1999
Who helps
Tools: Feeding Prep · Birthworker Directory
Related
- Getting a deep latchFeeding Your Baby
- Tongue and lip tiesFeeding Your Baby
- Flange sizingFeeding Your Baby
- Thrush and other nipple infectionsPostpartum: Your Body
- Nipple shields: when they help, how to wean offFeeding Your Baby
- Finding a lactation consultant (and what IBCLC means)Feeding Your Baby
What mothers here say
No one has posted under this topic yet. The first experience here will help the next mother who searches for it at 2 a.m.
Experiences and questions are their authors' own, not reviewed advice. The topic's steward lists the ones that help most in a credited digest once there is one. Unusual experiences stay, with a note.
Sources
- Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine — Clinical protocol on persistent pain with breastfeeding
- Cochrane — Interventions for treating painful nipples among breastfeeding women
- La Leche League International — Sore nipples
- NHS — Sore or cracked nipples when breastfeeding
Sources are named, not yet linked. The steward verifies each one and adds the link.
Steward this topic
Birthworkers listed in our directory can claim a topic, verify its sources, and curate what mothers share here. Your name and credential go at the top of the page. Takes about an hour the first time.
Find your directory page